Brian Hamilton-Vise

I know that what I am asking is impossible. But in our time, as in every time, the impossible is the least that one can demand. —James Baldwin

It Is Not Arrogant to Disagree

I. Error is systematic, harder to recognize as time passes and misunderstanding compounds. A simple mistake can pass into common sense, become the reason for another judgment, and thus quietly disappear from the conversation.

II. Recognizing error is less often a matter of intelligence than of circumstance: being in a position to see anew.

III. Sometimes an error only becomes evident by its consequences. A bad consequence does not immediately negate the original judgment, but it does call the judgment back into discussion.

IV. If calling into question long-held positions is sometimes performed in arrogance, it is not always or necessarily so. Pray for humility.

23 March 2007 | Comments (0)
Tags:

[RSS for this post]

No Comments »

No comments yet.

Leave a comment

Brian Hamilton-Vise is a Ph.D. student in moral theology at the University of Notre Dame, where his research is in the history of Christian political and economic thought. His side interests are in the development of negative theology and in recent political theory. Email him at bdhamilton@gmail.com.

[Subscribe to RSS Feed]  Subscribe to my RSS feed

Recent bookmarks